Evaluation

Each tool below was mapped onto the feature model, and every mapping here is the output of the mapping skills — not a hand-made assessment. The tools are grouped by the paper they were drawn from.

What each tool page shows

Automated mapping

What codebase-map or docs-map produced from the tool's own code or documentation, unedited.

Revised mapping

The same mapping after the authors re-checked the cited evidence and corrected it. Both are published so the corrections are visible.

Proposed model extension

Where a tool had a feature the model lacked, that feature was added to a copy of the model. These are the authors' proposals, not skill output, and only three tools produced one.

Colour legend

• Group fully mappedEvery feature in the group was mapped to the tool (feature groups only, never leaves)
• MappedThe feature was mapped to the tool
• Unmapped (optional)The feature was not mapped to the tool, but it is optional
• Unmapped (mandatory)The feature was not mapped to the tool, although it was mandatory
• Constraint violationThe feature was not mapped to the tool and this violates a constraint
• Inconclusive / extraThe mapping of this feature is inconclusive (automated mapping), or the feature is present in the tool but absent from the model

Tools

Tools that could not be mapped

These appear in the source papers but have no public codebase or documentation to map against.